Purpose: In this study, we articulate and share our knowledge and understanding of teaching and learning Sport Education in physical education teacher education (PETE): (a) How did the PETE faculty member experience teaching about teaching Sport Education? and (b) How did the PSTs experience learning about teaching Sport Education? Method: One PETE faculty member (the first author) and twelve PSTs took part in a university Sport Education unit. Data were collected through the PETE faculty member's open-ended reflective diary and focus groups with three PST teams. Results: The PETE faculty member and PSTs experienced various challenges such as bridging theory and practice when learning about teaching Sport Education and articulating the "what", "how" and "why" when teaching about teaching Sport Education. Conclusion: Sport Education is a complex curriculum and instructional model, encouraging further interrogation of the theoretical implications of the model.