In this article, we draw from cultural historical theory to examine the assimilationist forces embodied by English as a Second Language (ESOL) identification and programming practices in and outside of Georgia. We argue that the categorization of Spanish-speaking schoolchildren as Limited English Proficient is an extension of historical subtractive practices grounded in monolithic assumptions of what it means to be "American." Along the way, U.S. Latino/as' exceptionality and potential for additive bilingualism are ignored, and generations are routed into remediation tracks that leave most of them behind others academically and otherwise. We conclude by conceptualizing how a "Cultural Identity Plus" (CID+) policy as a key component in a broader lifespan strategy for dismantling "Group Based Inequality" (Portes, 2005) might counteract the harm caused by current practices.