This article delves into the pivotal role of Christian Athlete Circles as a new religious counter-space designed to foster inclusive spiritual growth for student-athletes, contrasting this organization with existing athlete ministries. Drawing from scholarly literature and informed by autoethnographic methods, the article highlights the necessity of such counter-spaces to support the well-being and flourishing of Christian student-athletes, particularly those who identify as LGBTQ+. It underscores the challenges posed by conservative theological beliefs, discusses mental health issues among student-athletes, and addresses recent anti-LGBTQ+ legislation. The research advocates for the creation of inclusive and affirming communities where student-athletes can authentically belong, ultimately enhancing their overall flourishing and well-being.