This article presents comments on the original article by McNulty and Fincham ("American Psychologist," v67 n2 p101-110 Feb-Mar 2012). McNulty and Fincham provided a service to the field of positive psychology through reminding us that whether psychological traits and processes yield positive or negative outcomes is a function of the interpersonal and cultural contexts in which they are expressed. They demonstrated this through their review of research on four qualities generally viewed by positive psychologists as inherently positive, specifically, forgiveness, optimistic expectations, positive thoughts and benevolent attributions, and kindness. However, they took a step too far in their conclusion that different outcomes in differing contexts mean that these and other psychological traits and processes should not be labeled as positive or negative. The current author provides suggestions on how the outcomes can be improved.