In this article, we investigate the artistic puzzle of designing mathematics experiences (MEs) to engage young children with ideas of group theory, using a combination of hands-on and computational thinking (CT) tools. We elaborate on: (1) group theory and why we chose it as a context for young mathematicians' experiences with symmetry and transformations; (2) our ME design principles of agency, access, surprise and audience; (3) the affordances of CT that complement our design principles; and (4) three ME variations we tested in grades 3-6 classrooms. We then reflect on the ME variations based on our design principles and the affordances of CT, and consider how the MEs may be further adapted and improved.