This article shows how equity research in mathematics education can be decentered by reporting the "voices" of mathematically successful African American male students as they recount their experiences with school mathematics, illustrating, in essence, how they negotiated the White male math myth. Using post-structural theory, the concepts "discourse", "person/identity", and "power/agency" are reinscribed or redefined. The article also shows that using a post-structural reinscription of these concepts, a more complex analysis of the multiplicitous and fragmented robust mathematics identities of African American male students is possible--an analysis that refutes simple explanations of effort. The article concludes, not with "answers," but with questions to facilitate dialogue among those who are interested in the mathematics achievement and persistence of African American male students--and equity and justice in the mathematics classroom for all students. (Contains 7 footnotes.)