For the first time ever, Citizen Through Sports Alliance (CTSA) convened a panel of youth sports experts from across the country to evaluate youth sports in the United States and articulate its successes and failures. The panel evaluated only community-based youth sports programs, focusing on those that serve children ages 6 to 14. The panel is composed of men and women from all over the country whose diverse experiences with youth sports brought a unique perspective. This article presents the ratings provided by the panel in the 2005 Youth Sports National Report Card.