We aimed to model the direct effects of the theorized relationships of academic self-efficacy, computer use self-efficacy, learning management system self-efficacy, internet and information-seeking self-efficacy, and online learning self-efficacy using structural equation modeling. The study proves that academic self-efficacy has positive predictive relationships with computer use self-efficacy, learning management system self-efficacy and internet and information self-efficacy. Secondly, modeling revealed that computer use self-efficacy, learning management system self-efficacy and internet and information self-efficacy positively predicts online learning self-efficacy. This study provides empirical evidence on a previously theorized set of relationships and informs policy makers on significant relationships they can employ to inform program development aimed at improving online learning self-efficacy anchored on their particular use cases.