In this article, the author explores the "algebra for all" issue to raise awareness about the many facets of this dilemma facing educators at the middle and high school levels. She discusses both sides of this controversial issue, especially regarding its impact on students' futures relative to higher education and employment. The author concludes that unless dramatic reform occurs in the delivery of algebra so that all students benefit from such instruction, students must make the decision to take algebra based on individual needs, interests, and desires.