Complete response vectors of all answer options in multiple-choice items can be used to estimate ability. The rising selection ratios criterion is necessary for scoring individuals because it implies that estimated ability always increases when the correct alternative is selected. This paper introduces the generalized DLT model, which assumes rising selection ratios and uses three parameters to describe each incorrect alternative. It is shown that the nominal categories and the Thissen and Steinberg model do not meet the criterion. A simulation study on goodness of recovery and an example with real data are also included.