In this extended case method analysis, Black female undergraduate students engaged in reflective journal writing in an effort to identify unique factors that impacted their academic experiences at a religiously based PWI (RBPWI). Data was gathered through reflective journal writing, a feminist and culturally relevant research methodology, which provided Black female students the opportunity to reflect on their experiences at a RBPWI. Purposive sampling was used to select academically successful Black female students (N = 8) who then wrote about academic experiences, sources of motivation, and campus climate. Students responded to a series of open-ended questions in their reflective journal writing over a two-week period. A womanist approach guided the data analysis of the journal writings with a specific focus on themes related to spirituality, mothering, family, and solidarity. The findings of this study suggest that womanist factors such as mothering and spirituality are sources of academic motivation and resilience that help Black female students succeed at RBPWIs. Results from this research also indicated that Black female students prefer to be part of social groups and clubs on campus that promote solidarity and empowerment among Black women.