In this response to "A Quality of Giftedness," ("Gifted and Talented International" v27 n2 p13-71 2012) by Prof. Dr. Joan Freeman, John Anchan comments that Freeman's article raises a number of issues that challenge conventional train of thoughts. It is all about why one person can train endlessly and yet, never keep a tune, while another deaf human genius can compose a masterpiece. [This article is a response to Joan Freeman's "A Quality of Giftedness" (EJ1149563).]