ERIC Number: EJ1145622
Record Type: Journal
Publication Date: 2017
Abstractor: As Provided
Reference Count: 59
Teachers Interpreting Data for Instructional Decisions: Where Does Equity Come In?
Garner, Brette; Thorne, Jennifer Kahn; Horn, Ilana Seidel
Journal of Educational Administration, v55 n4 p407-426 2017
Purpose: Though test-based accountability policies seek to redress educational inequities, their underlying theories of action treat inequality as a technical problem rather than a political one: data point educators toward ameliorative actions without forcing them to confront systemic inequities that contribute to achievement disparities. To highlight the problematic nature of this tension, the purpose of this paper is to identify key problems with the techno-rational logic of accountability policies and reflect on the ways in which they influence teachers' data-use practices. Design/methodology/approach: This paper illustrates the data use practices of a workgroup of sixth-grade math educators. Their meeting represents a "best case" of commonplace practice: during a full-day professional development session, they used data from a standardized district benchmark assessment with support from an expert instructional leader. This sociolinguistic analysis examines episodes of data reasoning to understand the links between the educators' interpretations and instructional decisions. Findings: This paper identifies three primary issues with test-based accountability policies: reducing complex constructs to quantitative variables, valuing remediation over instructional improvement, and enacting faith in instrument validity. At the same time, possibilities for equitable instruction were foreclosed, as teachers analyzed data in ways that gave little consideration of students' cultural identities or funds of knowledge. Social implications: Test-based accountability policies do not compel educators to use data to address the deeper issues of equity, thereby inadvertently reinforcing biased systems and positioning students from marginalized backgrounds at an educational disadvantage. Originality/value: This paper fulfills a need to critically examine the ways in which test-based accountability policies influence educators' data-use practices.
Descriptors: Evidence Based Practice, Data Interpretation, Accountability, Educational Policy, Policy Analysis, Information Utilization, Grade 6, Mathematics Teachers, Faculty Development, Decision Making Skills, Instructional Improvement, Meetings, Video Technology, Protocol Analysis, Educational Practices, Equal Education
Emerald Group Publishing Limited. Howard House, Wagon Lane, Bingley, West Yorkshire, BD16 1WA, UK. Tel: +44-1274-777700; Fax: +44-1274-785201; e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org; Web site: http://www.emeraldinsight.com
Publication Type: Journal Articles; Reports - Research
Education Level: Grade 6; Intermediate Grades; Middle Schools; Elementary Education
Authoring Institution: N/A