If we want student leaders to be prepared for the workforce, we need to develop their managerial leadership behaviors while they are in school. Peterson and Peterson (2012) identified a set of critical managerial leadership behaviors that should be taught while students are in college. However, the empirical work was done at a single Southwest university. This manuscript replicates the Peterson and Peterson study at a Midwest university. In addition, it extends the research by having the subjects rank order the managerial leadership behaviors they initially selected. The results identify a set of managerial leadership behaviors that could be taught and practiced by student leaders while they are still in a university setting. These students could then enter the workforce prepared to lead and manage.