While many contemporary popular cultural discourses in the USA recognise and commodify children as distinct persons engaging in the middle-class project of expressive individuation, much public and early educational policy has simultaneously intensified the control and regulation of children, children's culture and children's bodies and emotions in early education settings. Prout suggests that late modern schooling might be characterised by "practices directed at greater surveillance, control and regulation of children" (304). This ethnographic study of a group of three-, four- and five-year-old children in a rural New England community preschool setting explores rural children's lived experiences resisting control and navigating contradiction through unruly, mischievous games and free play. This unruliness is situated in the context of escalating academic demands in early childhood education and resistant rural community culture(s).