ERIC Number: ED486481
Record Type: Non-Journal
Publication Date: 2004-Dec
Reference Count: 7
Shades of Belonging
Pew Hispanic Center
When census takers, pollsters or bureaucrats with application forms ask people to identify their race, most have no problem checking a box that corresponds to one of the five, standard, government-defined racial categories. In the 2000 Census, for example, 90 percent of the U.S. population was counted as either white, black, Asian, American Indian or Pacific Islander. Hispanics are the exception. While a little more than half picked one of the standard categories, some 15 million, 42 percent of the Hispanic population marked "some other race." Census 2000 and much other evidence suggests that Hispanics take distinctive views of race, and because their numbers are large and growing fast, these views are likely to change the way the nation manages the fundamental social divide that has characterized American society for 400 years. According to federal policy and accepted social science, Hispanics do not constitute a separate race and can in fact be of any race. The 2000 Census asked respondents first to mark off whether they were "Spanish/Hispanic/Latino" and then in a separate question to specify their race. Among those who identified themselves as Hispanics, nearly half (48 percent) were counted as white. Blacks made up two percent. The American Indian, Asian, and Pacific Islander categories each accounted for small fractions. Surprisingly, given the large number of Latinos whose parentage includes combinations of white, African and indigenous ancestries, only six percent described themselves as being of two or more races. The only racial identifier, other than white, that captured a major share of the Latino population (42 percent) was the non-identifier, "some other race" (SOR). That is a sizeable category of people, outnumbering the total U.S. population of Asians and American-Indians combined. "Some other race" is not exactly a political slogan or rallying cry. Nor is it a term anyone ordinarily would use in conversation or to describe themselves. So, who are the some-other-race Hispanics? And, what are they trying to tell us with their choice of this label? In order to explore these questions the Pew Hispanic Center examined microdata from the 2000 Census as well as information from surveys and focus groups conducted by the Center. The Census numbers show that Latinos who call themselves white and those who say they are some other race have distinctly different characteristics, and survey data show they have different attitudes and opinions on a variety of subjects. Consistently across a broad range of variables, Hispanics who identified themselves as white have higher levels of education and income and greater degrees of civic enfranchisement than those who pick the some other race category. The findings of this report suggest that Hispanics see race as a measure of belonging, and whiteness as a measure of inclusion, or of perceived inclusion. Appended are: (1) Consistency of Race Responses and Race Allocation; and (2) Data Sources.
Descriptors: Race, Pacific Islanders, American Indians, Hispanic Americans, Census Figures, Racial Attitudes, Racial Discrimination
Pew Hispanic Center, a project of the University of Southern California Annenberg School for Communication, 1919 M Street NW, Suite 460, Washington, DC 20036. Tel: 202-452-1702; Fax: 202-785-8282; Web site: http://www.pewhispanic.org.
Publication Type: Reports - Evaluative
Education Level: N/A
Authoring Institution: Pew Hispanic Center, Washington, DC.