Stimulation paradigms that induce perforant path long-term potentiation (LTP) initiate phosphorylation of ERK1/2 and induce expression of a variety of immediate early genes (IEGs). These events are thought to be critical components of the mechanism for establishing the changes in synaptic efficacy that endure for hours or longer. Here we show that in mice, perforant path LTP can be induced using a standard protocol (repeated trains at 250 Hz), without accompanying increases in immunostaining for p-ERK1/2 or increased in expression of representative IEGs (Arc and c-fos). Signaling pathways capable of inducing ERK phosphorylation and IEG transcription are intact in mice because ERK phosphorylation differs strikingly in awake versus anesthetized mice, and IEG expression is strongly induced by electroconvulsive seizures. In pursuing the reasons for the lack of induction with LTP, we found that in rats, one of the stimulation paradigms used to induce perforant path LTP (trains at 250 Hz) also does not activate MAP kinase or induce IEG expression, despite the fact that the LTP induced by 250 Hz stimulation requires NMDA receptor activation and persists for hours. These findings indicate that there are different forms of perforant path LTP, one of which does not require MAP kinase activation or IEG induction. Moreover, these data demonstrate that different LTP induction paradigms do not have identical molecular consequences, which may account for certain discrepancies between previous studies.