In this article, the author points out that it is discouraging to see critics still firing broadsides at strategic planning, an imperative as old as Western Civilization. Without exception, these salvos, whether prompted by misunderstanding or negative experience, lack both sensible tactic and sufficient charge, so they tend to quickly dissipate in clamor and smoke. Usually, they are little more than amusing distractions. But the discharge titled "Tipping Point," by Mike Schmoker, which appeared in the February 2004 Phi Delta Kappan, may actually serve a serious instructional purpose. In this article, the author responds to Mike Schmoker's article.