In a birth cohort prenatally exposed to rubella, we assessed whether prospectively documented premorbid neuromotor dysfunction, mannerisms, deviant behaviors, and temperament during childhood and adolescence were impaired in cases who developed depressive disorder (DD) relative to rubella-exposed controls and cases who developed schizophrenia spectrum psychosis (SSP). Premorbid neuromotor dysfunction and mannerisms were not increased among DD cases compared to controls or SSP cases. With regard to temperament, approachability was greater in DD cases than in controls and SSP cases. There were numerical increases in the proportions of DD cases with premorbid deviant behaviors compared to controls, but the findings fell short of statistical significance; the proportion of subjects with deviant behaviors in DD cases was similar to that found for SSP. These results indicate that premorbid neuromotor dysfunction and mannerisms may be specific to SSP among major psychiatric disorders in this cohort, and suggest that premorbid deviant behaviors are increased in both DD and SSP. Greater premorbid approachability may be associated with an increased risk of adult DD. Implications of these findings for school psychology are furnished.