By the end of the eighth grade, students are expected to have a basic understanding of the mechanism of basic genetic inheritance. However, these concepts can be difficult to teach. In this article, the author introduces a new learning tool that will help facilitate student learning and enthusiasm to the basic concepts of genetic inheritance. This activity helps students explore the inheritance of genetic traits over multiple generations, the role and effects of genetic mutations, the origin and impact of genetic diseases, and the methods used to predict and track the inheritance of genetic traits. In this investigation, students create paper creatures with a specified set of genetic traits, "breed" them, predict characteristics of offspring with and without mutations, and explore natural selection and evolution. (Contains 2 figures and 1 online resource.)