Comments on the original article by McNulty and Fincham (see record 2011-15476-001). In their article, the authors offered compelling evidence that constructs such as forgiveness and optimism can have both beneficial and adverse consequences, depending on the context. Their caution about labeling particular psychological processes as "positive" is timely and well-taken. However, the current author fears that their article propagates a misunderstanding of positive psychology--namely, that positive psychologists believe that the constructs or processes they investigate are "good" and should be promoted.