Professional leaders have identified clear roles for social workers involved in advance care planning (ACP), a facilitated process whereby individuals identify their preferences for future medical care; yet information about effective teaching practices in this area is scant. This study reports on the experiences of 14 social workers who participated in a nationally recognized, evidence-based ACP facilitator certification program. Researchers first analyzed data consisting of participants' in-depth reflective writings using an inductive thematic analysis process. Identified themes were subsequently grouped into three categories to characterize the "novice" experience of participants: "theoretical knowledge," "skill development," and "self-reflection." Findings underscore the importance of ACP training in social work education and the need for teachers to help learners better understand the process of professional skill development.