ERIC Number: ED336428
Record Type: RIE
Publication Date: 1990-Dec
Reference Count: N/A
An Argument-Based Approach to Validation.
Kane, Michael T.
The literature on validity provides much more guidance on how to collect various kinds of validity evidence than it does on which kinds of evidence to collect in specific cases. An argument-based approach to validation redresses the balance by linking the kinds of evidence needed to validate a test-score interpretation to the details of the interpretation. This approach can be summarized in terms of a six-step iterative process; the first three steps constitute the formative stage and the last three steps constitute the summative stage. The interpretation is defined as an interpretive argument leading from test scores to statements and/or actions and is validated by evaluating the plausibility of this argument. The evidence supporting the interpretive argument constitutes an argument for the validity of the corresponding interpretation. The details of this validity argument depend on the specific inferences and assumptions in the interpretive argument, but the process of evaluating the interpretive argument provides a general, argument-based approach to validation. A 40-item list of references and a glossary of selected terms are included. (Author/SLD)
Descriptors: Evaluation Methods, Formative Evaluation, Inferences, Models, Predictive Measurement, Research Methodology, Research Needs, Scores, Summative Evaluation, Test Interpretation, Test Validity
ACT Research Report Series, P.O. Box 168, Iowa City, IA 52243.
Publication Type: Reports - Evaluative
Education Level: N/A
Authoring Institution: American Coll. Testing Program, Iowa City, IA.
Identifiers: Argument Research; Validation Verification and Testing Techniques