ERIC Number: ED194886
Record Type: RIE
Publication Date: 1980-Aug
Reference Count: 0
Cognitive Styles and Miscue Analysis of Reading and Writing.
Ney, James W.
Fourth grade students' miscues occurring in signaled sentence combining exercises were compared with their reading miscues in a study relating cognitive style to miscue analysis of reading and writing. The records of 16 students were used, with reflective students and impulsive students so designated on the basis of their miscues per one-hundred words. Miscues of phonology (reading) and spelling (writing) correlated very highly, indicating that reading and writing are similar processes. Miscues of addition and substitution were more frequent in reading, while miscues of omission were more frequent in writing. Thus, miscues of phonology and spelling have as their source the manner in which linguistic units are stored in the mind and the manner in which rules relate these underlying forms to surface forms. Regarding cognitive style, the reflective students showed a much higher correlation between their reading and writing miscues than did either the total group of students or the impulsive students. Applying the results to instructional practice, teachers could teach reading and writing as mirror images of the same process so that similarities could be strengthened and differences emphasized. It also appears that reading and writing lessons could be designed for groups of students who have similar records. (RL)
Publication Type: Reports - Research; Information Analyses; Speeches/Meeting Papers
Education Level: N/A
Authoring Institution: N/A
Note: Paper presented at the Annual International Conference on the Teaching of English (3rd, Sydney, Australia, August 17-22, 1980).